Skip to main contentSkip to footer

Fans are saying the same thing about Agatha and the Midnight Murders

Did you tune into the new drama? 

agatha midnight
Emmy Griffiths
TV & Film Editor
Share this:

Following the huge success of All Creatures Great and Small, Channel 5 aired a new feature-length drama, Agatha and the Midnight Murders on Wednesday night. But did the new show live up to expectations? 

READ: All Creatures Great and Small: will there be a season two?

Taking to Twitter to discuss the new film, viewers suggested that the dialogue was a little challenging, with one writing: "Might have just had too many painkillers, but can’t get to grips with #AgathaAndTheMidnightMurders on Channel 5. Really want to like it, but dialogue and plotting feels laboured." 

WATCH: Did you enjoy the Channel 5 drama?

Another added: "I have given it longer than it deserved, but I am abandoning it now. The plot is weird and boring, and the dialogue is awful." A third person tweeted: "Not the best dialogue is it?" 

agatha 5

Helen Baxendale and Blake Harrison star in the new film

However, some viewers enjoyed the new film, which stars Helen Baxendale as Agatha Christie. One person wrote: "Wasn't great but still better than Kenneth's movie (imo) - and no doubt made for a fraction of his massive budget." Another added: "Called it. Classic Christie tactic & one of my faves. The untrustworthy sidekick. And the nods to various stories. Plus the false conclusion. Enjoyed that very much." 

MORE: Meet the cast of All Creatures Great and Small

MORE: The true story behind BBC's shocking documentary Murder Case

MORE: Where is Foyle's War star Michael Kitchen now?

The film follows Agatha during the Blitz, as she decides to kill off her most famous creation. The synopsis reads: "After twelve Poirot novels in six years, Agatha should be a rich woman. Instead, she’s struggling to make ends meet: America’s financial chokehold of Britain has cut off royalties and the tax authorities in the US and UK are investigating her.

midnight murder© Photo: Channel 5

Did you enjoy the Channel 5 show?

"Killing her most popular character in the midst of this turmoil seems almost spiteful. But Agatha, pragmatic and resourceful as ever, has a plan: she is selling the novel of Poirot’s death to a private buyer, a superfan who will pay a fortune to own a piece of history and keep the beloved detective alive." 

Like this story? Sign up to our newsletter to get other stories like this delivered straight to your inbox.