While many successful love stories have come out of Love Island USA, several of the winners are no longer together.
The winners of the first season were Elizabeth Weber and Zac Mirabelli. While the couple took home $100,000, they broke up just a few months after leaving the island. Five years later, in 2024, Elizabeth got engaged to boyfriend Gianni Settino. The couple is set to get married this summer. As for Zac, he keeps his relationship status private.
Caleb Corprew and Justine Ndiba won the second season of Love Island USA, becoming the first Black couple to win the franchise. The season concluded in September 2020, and the couple announced their breakup in January 2021.
After three seasons, Love Island USA still wasn't able to produce a successful couple. The winners Korey Gandy and Olivia Kaiser broke up four months after leaving the villa. Korey announced the news on Instagram.
These days, while it seems Korey is single, Olivia is engaged to fellow reality star and Love Island UK alum Theo Campbell. The couple are parents to son Atlas Kaiser, who was born in November 2025.
The winners of Love Island USA season four, Timmy Pandolfi and Zeta Morrison, broke up just four months after the show wrapped. Zeta revealed their split in January 2023, saying: "Timmy and I are no longer together, so there's no more 'Zimmy.'"
Lastly, Amaya Espinal and Bryan Arenales, the winners of season 7, broke up before the reunion aired, which was just a month after they left the island.