Now former contestant Sara Beth Liebe, 25, left the 21st season of the show on its latest installment, opting to go back home to her three children.
The California-native first got attention for her time on the show after she called out the "Firework" singer on TikTok for what she felt was a mom-shaming comment from her, which you can see in the video below.
Initially, there were mixed reactions to the contentious moment, with many fans coming to Katy's defense, writing on social media: "She didn't shame her. She made a joke," and: "She DID NOT shame her!!" as well as: "I didn't hear anything offensive."
During the latest AI episode, the former contestant came to the conclusion that she wasn't cut out for the competition and went home, though not before Katy tried to convince her not to.
Though she went through with her rendition of The Police's 1978 hit "Roxanne" for the judges – which also include Luke Bryan and Lionel Richie – she announced she was leaving when she finished her performance.
She told them: "This opportunity is really rad but this is actually gonna be my last performance 'cause my heart's at home," continuing: "So I'm gonna get home to my babies, they kind of need me. So thank you, thanks."
Katy then told her: "Sara Beth, I know life is scary," adding: "I also know that it's easier to walk away than to be rejected. But then I also know that you lose out on your fullest potential."
She further said: "I know that you love your family for your kids. I know that as a mother. But remember, self-love is just as big as motherly love. Don't leave the competition," though the mom-of-three maintained she wasn't "cut out for show business."
The controversial dynamic between the two first began during her audition, when the judges expressed their shock over Sara Beth not being a teenager, claiming that she looked much younger than 25.
After she stated her age and that in fact she has three kids, Katy first pretended to faint, prompting Sara Beth to say: "If Katy lays on the table I might pass out." The American Idol judge then sparked controversy when she quickly fired back with: "Honey you've been laying on the table too much!"
Read more HELLO! US stories here
Like this story? Sign up to our newsletter to get other stories like this delivered straight to your inbox.