Skip to main contentSkip to footer

Chicago Fire: fans go wild after Matt Casey's finale comeback ends with major cliffhanger

Jesse Spencer returned as fan favorite Casey for the final episode


Jesse Spencer stands by engine in Chicago Fire© NBC
Francesca Shillcock
Senior Features Writer
May 25, 2023
Share this:

Chicago Fire fans were overjoyed to see Jesse Spencer return as fan favorite character Captain Matt Casey in the season 11 finale. However, they were left on the edge of their seat with the episode's major cliffhanger.

The actor, who also made a surprise return to the NBC show earlier in the series, came back to reprise his role in the dramatic episode and left audiences shocked when he got down on one knee to propose to on-screen love interest Sylvie Brett (Kara Killmer) but before fans got to see whether the pair officially got engaged – the screen went black.

WATCH: Peter Mills says goodbye to Firehouse 51 in Chicago Fire

Viewers took to social media to share their reactions to the proposal and it seems they were going wild after being left on such a huge cliffhanger. One person wrote: "Casey propose to Brett and I am just freaking out right now to know her ANSWER #ChicagoFire."

MORE: Chicago Fire: Will Taylor Kinney return following season 12 cast cuts? 

MORE: Chicago Fire: why did Peter Mills actor Charlie Barnett leave the show? 

Matthew Casey proposes to Sylvie Brett in final episode© NBC
Casey proposed to Brett in the season finale

A second echoed this, tweeting: "Arghhhh she better say yes. Pleasssee let Casey have a happy ending too." A third added: "#ChicagoFire really gonna play us like that with that ending? The nerve!" While a fourth commented: "Yes!!! He proposed!!! MATT CASEY PROPOSED TO SYLVIE BRETT!!! The way I screamed!!!!! #Brettsey is endgame!! What a sweet proposal!!! #ChicagoFire."

Although fans were overjoyed to see Casey get down on one knee and propose to the love of his life, Chicago Fire has some serious questions to answer. Before the romantic moment played out on screen, viewers were told that Brett has adopted a baby girl and is over the moon. What will this mean for Brett and Casey moving forward? And will Casey leave Portland and return for good?

Jesse Spencer hides behind car in Chicago Fire finale© NBC
Jesse Spencer in Chicago Fire finale

The news that Jesse was returning for the finale was confirmed by the show earlier this month and after his brief return for the episode titled Danger Is All Around, many were left hoping that his return would be permanent.

Is Jesse Spencer returning to Chicago Fire for good?

Chicago Fire haven't revealed if Casey's return to the show is permanent but given the proposal and evidently important storyline between him and Brett, it's certainly likely that the actor will be back in the fall for season 12.

Jesse Spencer spoke to Deadline in April about his potential permanent residency in the cast but remained cryptic: "The potential to come back would be awesome. I'm always open to that but you know, the ball isn’t really in my court.

CHICAGO FIRE -- "The Man of the Moment" Episode 1113 -- Pictured: (l-r) Assaf Cohen as Alexander, Taylor Kinney as Kelly Severide, Kara Killmer as Sylvie Brett© Getty
Taylor Kinney as Kelly Severide and Kara Killmer as Sylvie Brett on Chicago Fire

"I always told [series co-creator] Derek Haas that if there were episodes that he thought would be appropriate for me to come back, then I'm totally open to that because I want to see the old gang and I love working there. But in terms of me coming back full-time or something, I have no idea." 

Sylvie Brett and Matt Casey talk outside Firehouse 51© NBC
Sylvie Brett and Matt Casey in Chicago Fire
Jesse Spencer was last on the show in season ten© NBC
Jesse Spencer was last permanently on the show in season ten
Taylor Kinney as Kelly Severide in Chicago Fire© NBC
Taylor Kinney left Chicago Fire in season 11

Don't want to miss a story? Sign up to our What to Watch newsletter and get the heads-up on the shows and films everyone’s talking about.

Sign up to HELLO Daily! for the best royal, celebrity and lifestyle coverage

By entering your details, you are agreeing to HELLO! Magazine User Data Protection Policy. You can unsubscribe at any time. For more information, please click here.