Skip to main contentSkip to footer
Hoda on The Kelly Clarkson Show© Weiss Eubanks/NBCUniversal via G

Hoda Kotb is certain this big star could be Jenna Bush Hager's new Today co-host

The former TODAY host has some big opinions

Tess Hill
News and Features Writer
June 6, 2025
Share this:

Hoda Kotb has opinions on Jenna Bush Hager's options for co-host. The former TODAY show host recently sat down with Andy Cohen on Watch What Happens Live and gave her candid take on who might get the job.

"The contenders are Savannah [Guthrie]," Hoda said when asked who she thinks the new co-host will be. "Justin Sylvester is amazing. Scarlett Johansson crushed it."

Ever since Hoda left Hoda & Jenna in January of this year, Jenna has filled her seat with rotating guests. Everyone from Keke Palmer to Eva Longoria. Fans have been eagerly awaiting news of who might officially step into the role. Jenna even poked fun at the process on TikTok, comparing it to dating, noting that she is waiting to find the right person.

Hoda and Andy Cohen© Getty Images for Joy 101
Hoda and Andy Cohen

"We definitely want somebody permanent at some point just because that's our show, and I think the TODAY show is such a family," she said to PEOPLE at the Read with Jenna book festival in Nashville.

Viewers noticed particularly good chemistry with both Scarlett and Justin. Scarlett, who is best known for her role as Black Widow and as the founder of her beauty brand The Outset, co-hosted the show for an entire week. "She said [hosting] was her favorite job," Hoda shared.

"I mean… she's not going to do it every day," Andy said, pointing out Scarlett's already busy schedule as an actress and mom.

TODAY -- Pictured: Jenna Bush Hager and Scarlett Johansson on Thursday, January 23 2025© Getty Images
Scarlett loved her time on the show

Scarlett called the experience "a fantasy job" and compared it to hosting Saturday Night Live.

"The live element of it is really fun," she said.

Justin, best known for his work on E! News and Daily Pop, also hit it off with Jenna, especially after their big night out at Beyoncé's Cowboy Carter tour.

Hoda also mentioned Matt Rogers, co-host of Las Culturistas with Bowen Yang, as a potential pick. And she praised TODAY's own Sheinelle Jones, who is taking time off after the tragic death of her husband Uche Ojeh.

Jenna and Justin know how to have fun© Nathan Congleton/NBC via Getty I
Jenna and Justin had great chemistry

In the six months since leaving the show, Hoda enjoys spending quality time with her daughters, Haley, 8, and Hope, 6. She recently announced that Hope was diagnosed with Type-1 diabetes.

"As anyone with a child who has Type 1 (knows), you're constantly watching, you're constantly monitoring, you're constantly checking," she explained, adding that the diagnosis brought a new perspective to her life.

TODAY -- Pictured: Hoda Kotb with daughters Hope and Haley Joy on Wednesday, January 10, 2025© Getty Images
Hoda and her daughters

Despite stepping back from the anchor desk, Hoda's affection for her former co-host shines through.

"Anybody would be so lucky," she said of working with Jenna.

As Jenna continues her search for the perfect co-host, Hoda's endorsement of Scarlett, Justin, and others offers a glimpse into the camaraderie behind the scenes. And, it's a nice reminder of just how much Hoda cares for her friend Jenna.

Hoda Kotb Surprised Jenna Bush Hager At Studio 1A

Join HELLO! Daily and get the latest celebrity news, exclusive interviews, and top stories

By entering your details, you are agreeing to HELLO! Magazine User Data Protection Policy. You can unsubscribe at any time. For more information please click here.

More Celebrity News
See more