Skip to main contentSkip to footer

Simon Cowell's comment on AGT: All Stars act gets boos from audience

The BGT star is known for his tough takes


simon cowell agt all star cute© Photo: Getty Images
Ahad Sanwari
Ahad Sanwari - New York
Senior WriterNew York
February 7, 2023
Share this:

No one can dish out a tough critique quite like Simon Cowell, and such was the fate for Eric Chien on America's Got Talent: All Stars.

The magician returned to the show to prove himself to the judges after perfecting his skills, but he had a particular bone to pick with Simon.

VIDEO: The moment that forced Howie Mandel to walk away on AGT

He explained that the TV veteran challenged him to up his performances and make them "big," and by sticking to his preferred close-up magic, it cost him his spot in the competition.

Eric aimed to impress Simon and the rest of the judges with his impressive close-up magic routine, with Heidi Klum and Howie Mandel clearly quite taken with the young talent.

MORE: Watch Howie Mandel jump out of his seat after AGT contestant's health confession

TRENDING NOW: NCIS: Los Angeles star Daniela Ruah's next project following cancelation revealed

However, the dad-of-one still wasn't convinced, and while he gave them their plaudits, he still felt like it wasn't what he was looking for.

"I like big magic, these guys love small magic. So I thought it was cute," he said, immediately receiving a barrage of boos from the audience.

View post on Instagram
 

Simon's critique for Eric's performance elicited boos from the audience

He did reassure Eric that regardless of his take, it wasn't up to him, as the decision lay in the hands of the AGT superfans for the last spot in the finals.

This isn't the first time this season that Simon disagreed with his fellow judges, with the same taking place after the second audition episode with mentalist Peter Antoniou.

MORE: Simon Cowell's fiancée Lauren's big-budget engagement ring following exotic proposal

ALSO POPULAR: Simon Cowell shares very rare photos of son Eric during sweet outing – and he's so grown up

Howie immediately proclaimed his love for the act before it even started, which entailed the magician reading the minds of his subjects.

For this, he chose Howie, host Terry Crews, and a random member from the audience, and sought out to answer their questions one by one.

View post on Instagram
 

The TV judging icon is no stranger to disagreeing with his judges

However, before he could finish, he received the dreaded red X from Simon, leaving Peter rattled, and receiving the critique from Simon that his "showmanship" was lacking.

Even after the psychic left the stage, the three huddled for a heated discussion on the matter, and Peter joked to Terry that he was buzzed because Simon was "scared of what I know about him."

Read more HELLO! US stories here

Like this story? Sign up to our newsletter to get other stories like this delivered straight to your inbox.

Sign up to Off Camera for all the gossip and goings-on from the wonderful world of TV and film

By entering your details, you are agreeing to HELLO! Magazine User Data Protection Policy. You can unsubscribe at any time. For more information, please click here.

More TV and Film

See more