Skip to main contentSkip to footer

Chiara Ferragni's Pandoro scandal stirs up a £1 million fine, here's why it matters

Charity charm or social media scandal? Our digital editor weighs in


Chiara Ferragni is seen before the Chanel show at the Grand Palais during Paris Fashion Week Womenswear Fall/Winter 2017/2018  on March 7, 2017 in Paris, France.  (Photo by Claudio Lavenia/Getty Images)
Natalie Salmon
Fashion Digital Editor
On 23 December 2023
Share this:

The buzz surrounding Chiara Ferragni is, for once, not due to her impeccable style. 

Recent events have placed her in the spotlight for entirely different reasons. The Italian influencer, known for her fashion-forward sense and entrepreneurial endeavours, has been embroiled in a controversy that has rippled through social media.

What is the Chiara Ferragni scandal about?

Ferragni, with a following nearly the size of a small country, found herself under fire for misleading promotional claims about a charity campaign tied to Pandoro sales, a holiday cake that is a lighter alternative to the traditional Panettone. Followers believed that the sales would help fund a children's hospital in Turin. The consequences were swift and costly: a fine of €1,075,000 (£927,000) imposed for the misrepresentation. 

The festive "Pandoro Pink Christmas" cake, marketed under Ferragni's brand, retailed last year at a significant markup compared to standard versions by Balocco. Regulators determined that consumers were misled to think their purchase would fund medical equipment for the children's hospital treating rare bone cancers.

What was Chiara Ferragni's response?

In response, Ferragni has put forth an explanation citing a "communication error" and has announced a donation of  €1,000,000 to the Regina Margherita hospital. "Unfortunately you can make a mistake, I regret having done it and I realise that I could have been more vigilant... My mistake remains but I want to ensure that something constructive and positive arises from this mistake."

Chiara Ferragni in black hot pants and spotted tights © Getty
Chiara Ferragni attended the Schiaparelli Haute Couture SS23 show

In an emotional message to her audience, Chiara Ferragni admitted to unintentionally conflating a business initiative with a philanthropic effort. She plans to contest the decision and the hefty fine levied by Italy's AGCM watchdog, which she believes is excessive and unfair.

View post on Instagram
 

Despite her apology and contribution, Ferragni is challenging the fine, which she deems excessive and unjust. This stance has sparked discussions on the responsibilities of influencers, the transparency required in charity affiliations, and the accountability of public figures in their promotional endeavours.

Adding to the complexity, Balocco, the cake manufacturer, is also facing penalties for its part in the controversy. The incident has become a cautionary tale about the intertwining of commerce and philanthropy, highlighting the need for clear and honest communication, especially when charity is involved.

Why does it matter?

Ferragni's case is particularly instructive for the fashion community, which often partners with charitable causes. It underscores the importance of due diligence and ethical marketing. As much as we admire Ferragni for her trendsetting and business acumen, this episode serves as a reminder that even the most glamorous among us are not immune to the repercussions of oversight in the digital age, where every claim is subject to scrutiny.

Chiara Ferragni in gold earrings and a black strappy top © Getty
Chiara has a net worth of €19,000,000

As the legal proceedings continue, the fashion world watches with bated breath, not only for the outcome but also for the precedent it will set. The Ferragni Pandoro scandal may well redefine the nexus of influence  for years to come.

More Culture

See more