Skip to main contentSkip to footer

Who will replace Douglas Henshall on Shetland? Fans share their theories

The actor will be leaving the BBC drama after series seven


shetland douglas replacement
Francesca Shillcock
Senior Features Writer
On 24 August 2022
Share this:

Shetland's Douglas Henshall disappointed fans when he announced that he would be stepping down from his iconic role as DI Jimmy Perez once series seven has wrapped.

MORE: Shetland star Douglas Henshall reveals plans to return after announcing shock exit

But it seems viewers have taken some enjoyment in trying to guess which actor could be replacing him for series eight onwards – and there are some pretty interesting theories already!

WATCH: Shetland is finally back for series seven - are you watching?

Taking to social media, fans have been voicing their thoughts on who the next lead detective could be. Although BBC are yet to announce a formal replacement, we're loving the viewers' suggestions.

One person seems convinced that Detective Sergeant Alison 'Tosh' McIntosh, played by Alison O'Donnell, is the perfect successor to lead future crime investigations on the show. "@djhenshall I have a theory about #Shetland," they wrote.

MORE: Shetland's Mark Bonnar has a very famous wife - and you might recognise her!

MORE: Shetland star Douglas Henshall reveals reason behind shock exit

shetland tosh© Photo: BBC

Some fans have said Tosh is the perfect choice to lead the show

"I predict that after Perez leaves this season, Tosh will replace him for the next season as head of dept. However, midway through the next season, she'll need his help in a case and she'll call Perez and get him to help her."

Another had a similar idea, tweeting: "I think Tosh probably will take over as the lead. In my head I would just love her and Jimmy to get married…"

Tosh isn't the only name that audiences are floating as a potential new lead. One fan thinks that Sergeant Billy McCabe, played by Lewis Howden, could be an good option. "I think Billy must be in line for the lead next series. He has been really busy this episode #Shetland," guessed a fan.

billy shetland© Photo: Rex

Others think Billy could be the new lead

However, there is a possibility that BBC will bring a brand new face into the Shetland family to lead the way, and one name that's been suggested will definitely be familiar to TV fans.

Martin Compston, a Scottish actor perhaps best-known for his role in other popular BBC crime drama Line of Duty, has been tipped by viewers to lead the cast from season eight onwards.

steve line of duty© Photo: BBC

Some fans have suggested Martin Compston

One fan theorised: "Someone suggested to me that @martin_compston should take over from [Douglas] next season of Shetland… and now I can't stop thinking about it. How does Jimmy's story end? Heroic death? Happy ever after with Meg?"

Another agreed, tweeting: "I reckon @martin_compston would be good as the new lead in #Shetland do u agree @djhenshall #Shetland." Only time will tell…

Like this story? Sign up to our What to Watch newsletter to get other stories like this delivered straight to your inbox.

Sign up to HELLO Daily! for the best royal, celebrity and lifestyle coverage

By entering your details, you are agreeing to HELLO! Magazine User Data Protection Policy. You can unsubscribe at any time. For more information, please click here.