Skip to main contentSkip to footer
Barbara Eden in 'I Dream of Jeannie'© Getty Images

I Dream of Jeannie's Barbara Eden, 93, reveals why she was left in tears over rejection related to her looks — details

The Harper Valley PTA actress' career spans over seven decades

Ahad Sanwari
Ahad Sanwari - New York
Senior WriterNew York
June 18, 2025
Share this:

Barbara Eden remains a touchstone of television and Hollywood, one of the most beloved stars of the classic era of sitcoms. But there was a point when it all felt like it wasn't worth it.

The actress, 93, made a recent appearance on Jennie Garth's podcast I Choose Me, speaking about their work together on the 1989 TV show Brand New Life, and the star's own rise to fame.

Barbara explained that for the longest time in her teens, she was interested in becoming a singer, and studied at the San Francisco Conservatory of Music. However, her mother Alice recommended she instead take up acting.

The Lineup (aka: San Francisco Beat).  A CBS television police drama, based on actual crimes in San Francisco, CA.  Episode, "The Samuel Bradford Case." Originally broadcast February 7, 1958. Pictured is Barbara Eden (as Eleanor).© CBS via Getty Images
Barbara's acting career began in the mid '50s

She began taking acting classes soon after, but during her second year of college, her teacher told her to study acting full-time, which she pursued for another couple of years before encouraging her to move to New York or Los Angeles. 

Barbara decided then to move in with her uncle and aunt in San Marino, California, joking she "went from one nest to another." The I Dream of Jeannie star also stayed at the studio club, where she and other women she was living with would audition for bit parts together.

However, she then remembered one incident, when she was still living with relatives, when she was sent to meet with a casting director at Warner Bros. "He knew my background. I told him everything, where I studied, what I did, how many plays I'd done, and I was a member of Actors' Equity."

Actress Barbara Eden best known for her starring role of 'Jeannie' in the TV sitcom 'I Dream of Jeannie' photographed in her Deep Canyon, Los Angeles bedroom with her 'magic lamp' from the hit TV series. April 1992.© Getty Images
A meeting with a Warner Bros. casting director left her discouraged about her looks

"And he looked at me and he said, 'You're just not Hollywood,'" she painfully recalled. He then shocked her when he pulled out a picture of his daughter, pointed at it and blurted out "big tits," saying that was what the industry wanted. In between Jennie's laughter, she pointed out that while it doesn't seem like a big deal now, it was back then.

Emphasizing that he thought she wasn't "pretty enough," she explained that the words left her stunned because "my father, my uncles never said that word, I never heard that word in my life."

Barbara Eden in character as Jeannie in I Dream of Jeannie© NBC
The star played the iconic Jeannie from 1965-1970

She remembered holding back the tears as she went back to her incensed uncle's car. However, fate had a different role to play, as she found herself face-to-face with the same casting director once again eight months later. Barbara had met a coach at the studio who asked her to work with him.

When she was on the lot, someone started shouting for her, and she was worried she'd be thrown out because she wasn't under contract, and it was the same man. "He said, 'Are you going up to so and so's room, you know, for the class?' I said, 'Yes. I am.'" 

Barbara cut a glamorous figure in a cherry red blazer and slim black pants © GARRETT PRESS/MEGA
"Then I thought, not everyone looks alike. You need different characters for every play."

And then he surprised her by saying they'd be offering her a screen test, the "same man that told me I wasn't pretty enough, I didn't have big tits" she recalled with a laugh. The Beverly Hills, 90210 star wondered how "devastating" that comment was for Barbara, who shared that she had gone home to her aunt and uncle's "and then I cried."

"And then I thought, not everyone looks alike. You need different characters for every play. What is going on here? I don't care. I'll be a character actress. I don't care if I'm not pretty enough."

Transform your routine with expert advice from our beauty and wellness team!

By entering your details, you are agreeing to HELLO! Magazine User Data Protection Policy. You can unsubscribe at any time. For more information please click here.

More Beauty
See more