Skip to main contentSkip to footer

Chicago Fire viewers complain about heartbreaking storyline

Fans aren't too pleased


chicago fire hermann© NBC
Nicky Morris
TV and film writer
January 19, 2023
Share this:

Chicago Fire fans have taken to Twitter to complain about the show's latest storyline involving Christopher Herrmann's (David Eigenberg) wife Cindy Herrmann, who is played by Robyn Coffin.

In last week's episode, Cindy was diagnosed with lung cancer. Her doctor suggested that she undergo surgery to remove the cancer, which we saw in Wednesday night's episode. 

WATCH: Are you enjoying the series so far? 

Cindy's treatment didn't exactly go to plan, however, with her doctor revealing that the surgeons couldn't remove all of the cancer.

"Unfortunately, we weren't able to get the margins clean," the doctor explained. "She made it through the surgery well, but we weren't able to get all the cancer out. We removed what we could, but we found some in the lymph nodes, too, which means we have a fight ahead of us. Next step: chemotherapy and radiation." 

The cliffhanger sent fans into a frenzy, with some taking to social media to complain about the heartbreaking storyline. 

MORE: Is Chicago PD star Jesse Lee Soffer returning for the 200th episode?

MORE: Chicago Fire: All the original cast members who left and why

One person wrote: "Not liking the upcoming storyline involving Cindy, Herman’s wife. Hope she is not written out of the show!" while another added: "Cindy having lung cancer… I don’t like this storyline."

chiago fire cindy© NBC

Fans complained about the heartbreaking storyline

"That scene at the dining room table was so beautifully acted by the kids. I hate this storyline. Please #ChicagoFire. Don’t kill Cindy. We won’t be able to take it."

Other viewers took to Twitter to express their concern for Cindy, with many pleading with the show not to kill her off. 

One person wrote: "Still heartbroken with Cindy having cancer," while another added: "How could you? Don't kill off Cindy. We need her!"

A third person commented: "NOTHING can happen to Cindy Herrmann. Not ONE thing! She must be protected at all costs. I will lodge a very loud protest!"

cindy chicago fire© NBC

Viewers expressed their concern for Cindy

The drama's co-showrunner Andrea Newman spoke about the storyline in a recent interview with NBC Insider. "It is going to be a rough road for the whole Herrmann family as Cindy battles lung cancer," she said. "There's a tough fight ahead, with no short cuts or easy solutions, but the Herrmann family, and the 51 family, will come together to help in all sorts of ways as the situation progresses."

Like this story? Sign up to our What to Watch newsletter to get other stories like this delivered straight to your inbox.

Sign up to Off Camera for all the gossip and goings-on from the wonderful world of TV and film

By entering your details, you are agreeing to HELLO! Magazine User Data Protection Policy. You can unsubscribe at any time. For more information, please click here.

More TV and Film

See more