Skip to main contentSkip to footer
AMERICA'S GOT TALENT -- "Quarter-Finale" Episode 1911 -- Pictured: (l-r) Howie Mandel, Heidi Klum, Sofia Vergara, Simon Cowell© Getty Images

Heidi Klum's surprise exit from America's Got Talent sparks fan confusion as famous former judge returns

The German supermodel will also be hosting the new season of Project Runway

Ahad Sanwari
Ahad Sanwari - New York
Senior WriterNew York
February 3, 2025
Share this:

It's official — America's Got Talent will return for a 20th season this summer, but without one of their regular judges.

Heidi Klum, after appearing in 11 of the show's last 12 seasons, has exited the show and will be replaced by returning judge Mel B, who last appeared in season 13.

A new promotional poster for the upcoming season was shared featuring returning judges Simon Cowell, Howie Mandel and Sofia Vergara, plus host Terry Crews. The new season will officially premiere on NBC on May 27.

Recommended videoYou may also likeWATCH: Sofia Vergara and Heidi Klum show off AGT outfits

While fans expressed excitement, many were also understandably confused and disappointed to see the German supermodel leave the show. 

They left comments on social media like: "Where is Heidi!????" and: "But I am sad that Heidi isn't here," as well as: "Yay for Mel B, boo for no Heidi," plus: "Mel B and Sofia! Can't wait! I will miss Heidi for sure!"

The Spice Girl served as a judge alongside Heidi from seasons 8-13, with both exiting in season 14, when they were replaced by Gabrielle Union and Julianne Hough. Heidi, 51, came back the following season, and Mel, 49, was replaced instead by Sofia.

America's Got Talent season 20© NBC
"America's Got Talent" season 20 will feature the return of Mel B

Howie, the longest serving judge, has been a regular on the panel since season 5, with Simon joining in season 11. Terry took over as host from Tyra Banks in season 14.

MORE: America's Got Talent star dies aged 17 weeks after taking part in show

While no official reason has been provided for Heidi's departure, it has been reported that she parted ways on good terms, likely due to conflicting schedules with Germany's Next Top Model and, most notably, Project Runway.

AMERICA'S GOT TALENT --  "Live Finale" Episode 1321 -- Pictured: (l-r, back to front) Howie Mandel, Simon Cowell, Mel B, Heidi Klum© Getty Images
The singer will return as a judge for the first time since season 13

Heidi announced that she'll be returning to host the new season of the Bravo design reality competition, which she initially was the face of from 2004-2017. Her return to Project Runway sparked speculation online that her schedule might be too full for AGT.

MORE: Heidi Klum looks phenomenal in gold mini dress on AGT red carpet

A representative for the show shared a statement over her exit with Deadline, which reads: "Heidi has been an incredible part of AGT, bringing her signature charm, expertise and warmth to the show." 

Model Heidi Klum walks the runway at the Project Runway fashion show during Spring 2016 New York Fashion Week: The Shows at The Arc, Skylight at Moynihan Station on September 11, 2015 in New York City© Getty Images
Heidi will return as the host of "Project Runway's" newest season

"We are enormously grateful for her many contributions and the impact she has had while celebrating the world’s greatest talent with us. We'd love for our paths to cross again." It is likely still that she could return to the show similarly to the way she did in season 15, given her strong friendships with her fellow judges, most notably Sofia.

MORE: Where are the child stars of America's Got Talent now?

Simon also shared a statement with the publication about the upcoming season, saying: "It is absolutely brilliant to be able to announce this year as our 20th season. Over the years, we have seen some amazing acts and met some truly incredible people." 

Heidi Klum attends the world premiere of Disney's Mufasa: The Lion King at the Dolby Theatre in Hollywood, California on December 09, 2024.© Getty Images
Heidi served as a judge on AGT for 11 seasons

"It's true that two or three minutes can change your life," he continued. "I want to thank every contestant, all the fans who have supported the show every year and to NBC for believing in this show. And of course, the amazing team, past and present, who make the show so special. Now as always, I am really excited to meet the contestants this year."

Sign up to our TV & Film newsletter for The Emmy Edit’s highlights and the latest releases in What to Watch

By entering your details, you are agreeing to HELLO! Magazine User Data Protection Policy. You can unsubscribe at any time. For more information, please click here.

More TV and Film

See more