Instead, Jennifer was flanked by Eva Pilgrim and Gio Benitez, who presented her with a gorgeous golf-themed birthday cake.
Jennifer posted a snapshot on Instagram and neither Amy nor T.J. commented or appeared to like the post.
The birthday girl wrote: "Nothing but love for my @abcgma3 work fam for this amazing (and fun) early birthday golf surprise!!!
"Thanks to all the crew and team who made this surprise happen and to @lpga_tour for inviting me to play in the day before the Pro-Am on May 10! There are not enough private lessons in the world to get me ready but I know it will be fun! #newobsession #golf #lpga #birthdayweekend."
Fans commented: "Happy birthday Jen," and "best golf cake ever".
Amy and T.J. were let go from the show in January after their extra-marital affair was exposed in November 2022.
They had all loved working together on the show and the trio previously opened up about their working relationship in Resident Magazine. "The three of us have been working and collaborating together on random segments for a while now," Jennifer said at the time.
"When Amy would anchor GMA, we had a joke between us – we would just always say we felt like we were in a tennis match or doing a dance, and that we wish we could do it all the time.
"I can't overstate the amount of respect and admiration I have for these guys and what they do on the air, especially when it comes to their range.
"It's like watching the G.O.A.T. of athletes everyday do their thing. I learn so much from them." Meanwhile, "trust and respect" are what they believed had led to the show's success.
On January 27 People released a statement from an ABC spokesman announcing Amy and T.J.'s departure: "After several productive conversations with Amy Robach and T.J. Holmes about different options, we all agreed it's best for everyone that they move on from ABC News.
"We recognize their talent and commitment over the years and are thankful for their contributions."
Read more HELLO! US stories here
Keep up with the latest celebrity stories Sign up to our HELLO! Mail newsletter and get them delivered straight to your inbox.