Skip to main contentSkip to footer
Simon Cowell© AFF-USA/Shutterstock

Simon Cowell makes 'dreadful' confession about AGT ahead of milestone season

The TV judge shares what he really thought about the show's pilot

Nova M Bajamonti
News and Features Writer
May 28, 2025
Share this:

America's Got Talent is the popular TV series that Simon Cowell is to thank for. Despite the show celebrating its 20th season, the TV talent competition's success was once highly doubted by Simon himself, believe it or not.

The TV judge transparently shared: "It was a difficult show to sell actually, to be honest with you. Because we made a pilot and the pilot was dreadful. I mean really, really bad. So, it was dead," per People.

Without hesitation, he called the seven-minute-long pilot "just about watchable." Simon wasn't a fan of the show's pilot at all, yet he continued to pitch it to networks. He recalled the time when NBC called him regarding the show.

AMERICA'S GOT TALENT -- "Quarter-Finale" Episode 1911 -- Pictured: (l-r) Howie Mandel, Heidi Klum, Sofia Vergara, Simon Cowell© Getty Images
The last America’s Got Talent judging panel

He shared: "They called me, and they said, 'What's this new show like?' And I went, 'Oh it's brilliant.' And they said, 'Can we have a look at it?' And I said, 'Yeah, come over to the house.'"

To Simon's surprise, NBC was hooked and the rest is history. The TV star recalled: "They came over and I just showed two minutes or three minutes of this show. And they loved it. They bought it. And that was it."

Simon didn't want to press the buzzer© ITV
Simon is the creator behind AGT

Regardless of Simon's harsh opinion of the pilot, he's grateful that others saw the vision he wanted for the show. He added: "If they hadn't made that call or come to my house that day, we wouldn't [be] having this conversation today because the show, honestly, it was over."

When it came to Simon's inspiration behind the show, he acknowledged that it came from his deep love for TV competitions growing up. Simon expressed: "I loved them. The kind of acts I remember as a kid were those really wacky acts, where it just used to crack me up."

Simon Cowell with son Eric and stepson Adam© AFP via Getty Images
Simon alongside his sons Adam and Eric

It was during his time as a judge on the Idol franchise, that he got the idea for AGT's creation. He recalled: "Once I'd done Idol and I enjoyed it, I kind of thought, 'I think I'd probably enjoy a show that has singers along with other acts.' It was a light bulb moment…and it evolved into what it is now."

The TV judge enjoys witnessing how the show has progressed over the years, and is a huge fan of the added quirks, such as the Golden Buzzers.

Season 12 winner ventriloquist Darci Lynne Farmer (L) and judge/executive producer Simon Cowell attend NBC's "America's Got Talent" season 12 finale at Dolby Theatre on September 20, 2017 in Hollywood, California© Getty Images
Season 12 winner ventriloquist Darci Lynne Farmer (L) and judge/executive producer Simon Cowell

Simon shared: "I've seen this sort of evolution over the years of how things have just gotten bigger and better, more creative. And that is a really, really good feeling when you see that."

The TV star loves seeing the new concepts and performers that audition for the show each season, and he recognizes that he's always seeing something new.

He added: "Personally, I think the best thing we ever did was to say, 'Why don't we have a competition, which is a talent competition, where there are no restrictions?' To have that kind of freedom is brilliant because you're not restricted by anything and you're always constantly surprised by what people come up with."

When you love what you do, it doesn't feel like you're working, and Simon gets just that. He shared: "We always say it is the best job in the world doing this."

Recommended videoYou may also likeAll About Simon Cowell

Sign up to HELLO TV & Film for the week's top talking points and the lowdown on the latest releases

By entering your details, you are agreeing to HELLO! Magazine User Data Protection Policy. You can unsubscribe at any time. For more information, please click here.

More TV and Film
See more