The stars of American Pie 25 years later: Tara Reid, Alyson Hannigan, Seann William Scott, more then vs now

Jason Biggs, now 47, continued to lead the franchise while also expanding into a movie and TV career including the likes of Saving Silverman (2001), My Best Friend's Girl (2008), and the critically acclaimed series Orange is the New Black.

He will next star in the film Getaway, also his directorial debut. He married his My Best Friend's Girl co-star Jenny Mollen in 2008 and they share two sons. Jason was briefly seen as a controversial figure between 2012-14 for his social media activity, particularly on X.

Chris Klein, now 46, mainly parlayed his success with the franchise into a TV career, with his most notable roles being in the series The Flash, Wilfred and most recently, the Netflix hit Sweet Magnolias.

He was in a relationship with and engaged to actress Katie Holmes before they called it off in 2005. In 2015, he married travel agent Laina Rose Thyfault and they now share a son and daughter.

Thomas Ian Nicholas, now 44, has also continued acting, with his other notable credits including The Rules of Attraction (2002), Halloween: Resurrection (2002), Stealing Sinatra (2003) and Walt Before Mickey (2015). He also made his musical debut in 2008.

He tied the knot in 2007 with Colette Marino (aka DJ Colette) and welcomed two children before their separation in 2022.

Seann William Scott, now 48, starred in several notable projects following American Pie, including Dude, Where's My Car? (2000), Final Destination (2000), The Dukes of Hazzard (2005), the Goon franchise, and the Ice Age franchise.

After a brief engagement to model Lindsay Frimodt, he tied the knot with interior designer Olivia Korenberg in 2019, welcoming one daughter before their 2024 divorce.

Alyson Hannigan, now 51, was already popular in 1999 thanks to her role in Buffy the Vampire Slayer, and followed that up with her most well-known project, playing Lily Aldrin on How I Met Your Mother from 2005 to 2014. 

Her other major TV stints include hosting Penn & Teller: Fool Us and the Disney series Fancy Nancy. Since 2003, she has been married to Buffy co-star Alexis Denisof and they share two daughters.

Once the '90s and early aughts' hottest commodity, Tara Reid, now 49, has stepped away from the spotlight, limiting her screen presence to more low-key roles and brief TV appearances. Her most notable credits since American Pie include Van Wilder (2002), Scrubs (2003-05) and the Sharknado series (2013-18).

Her highly-publicized personal life includes several brief relationships with the likes of entrepreneurs like Michael Axtmann, Michael Lillelund and Zachary Kehayov, plus a brief engagement to TV personality Carson Daly.

Already on the verge of becoming a breakout young star, Natasha Lyonne, now 46, is a major name in the world of TV thanks to acclaimed projects like Orange is the New Black (2013-19), Russian Doll (2019-22) and Poker Face (2023-present).

She has also branched out into producing, writing and directing, most notably with Russian Doll and Poker Face. Natasha keeps her personal life under wraps, but notably dated actor Fred Armisen from 2014-2022.

Mena Suvari, now 46, continued on the acclaim she also received that same year for American Beauty with other film successes like Six Feet Under (2004), Chicago Fire (2013), the American Horror Story franchise and the short-form series RZR (2024), which earned her an Emmy nod.

She also continues to model and remain an ambassador for Lancôme. She previously married Robert Brinkmann (2000-05) and Simone Sestito (2010-12) before finding love and welcoming a son with set decorator Michael Hope in 2018.

Eugene Levy, now 78, continued earning acclaim for projects like Best in Show (2000) and For Your Consideration (2006) before experiencing a major career resurgence playing Johnny Rose in the sitcom Schitt's Creek (2015-2020), which he co-created with his son Dan Levy.

The show earned him two Emmys and made him, Dan and his daughter Sarah (known for playing Twyla Sands) household names. His other notable roles include lending his voice to Over the Hedge (2006) and Finding Dory (2016), and hosting the series The Reluctant Traveler.

Jennifer Coolidge, now 63, became one of Hollywood's most recognizable character actors thanks to roles like the Legally Blonde franchise, A Cinderella Story (2004), For Your Consideration (2006), Promising Young Woman (2020) and 2 Broke Girls (2011-17).

The comedian earned major acclaim, two Primetime Emmys and a Golden Globe, however, for her turn as Tanya McQuoid in Mike White's The White Lotus in 2021-22.